The NYT is standing by its recent stories on deceased organ donation. In the meantime Newsweek has this story about people who have had second thoughts about deceased donation. (For the record, while it's very important to scrutinize current practices, none of the reported concerns even made me think about withdrawing from the donor registry.)
Mass Exodus From Organ Donor Registries Following Media Coverage by Joshua Rhett Miller
"Thousands of Americans have removed themselves from organ donor registries following "irresponsible reporting" led by the New York Times, officials said.
The Association of Organ Procurement Organizations, a trade group that represents 46 of the nation's 55 federally designated nonprofit entities that help facilitate donations, accused the newspaper of a "lack of balance and accuracy" in its recent coverage of the problems in the sprawling transplant system.
The letter, sent to three Times editors on Tuesday, cited two articles from July 20, including "A Push for More Organ Transplants Is Putting Donors at Risk," in which reporters Brian M. Rosenthal and Julie Tate detailed rushed or premature attempts to retrieve organs from patients who were, in some cases, still showing signs of life.
A third recent Times item, an op-ed written by three cardiologists in which they argue for a "new definition of death" to help alleviate the backlog of recipients in need of transplants, was not included in the letter. The essay has gone viral on X, with many users commenting it has made them rethink or actively change their status as organ donors.
...
"AOPO claims both articles contained "serious factual inaccuracies," including the trade group attributing "any errors to hospitals" in the story written by Rosenthal and Tate. That phrase wasn't a part of AOPO's response to the newspaper, which subsequently updated the article, according to Tuesday's letter.
"The main article from July 20 also omitted or misrepresented key facts in some donation cases," the letter continued. "The absence of critical context in the story has fueled massive mistrust in the donation process."
...
"This is the largest spike in registry removals ever recorded in the history of organ donation in the U.S.," AOPO letter reads. "The New York Times' coverage — coupled with a wave of secondary stories by other outlets and widespread, sensationalistic commentary and online reactions — has initiated a wave of panic and fear across the United States."
#########
Earlier:




